A comparative analysis of India's DPDP Act, the EU GDPR and California's CCPA (as amended by the CPRA) reveals divergent standards on legal bases, individual rights, breach notification and cross-border transfers — requiring multi-jurisdictional compliance strategies.
Introduction
India’s dedicated data privacy legislation, the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (DPDPA), marks a significant milestone in the country’s regulatory landscape. Building upon our previous newsletters, where we explored topics such as consent, rules and the foundational aspects of the DPDPA, in this edition we embark on a comparative journey, unravelling how the DPDPA intersects with two established global frameworks: the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) as amended by the California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA).
Following is a comparative study between the DPDPA, GDPR and CCPA:
1. Applicability
● GDPR: Applies to all organisations, whether based in the EU or outside it, that process the personal data of individuals in the EU in connection with offering goods or services to them or monitoring their behaviour, as well as to organisations established in the EU.
● CCPA (as amended by CPRA): Applies to for-profit businesses that collect personal information of California residents and meet the thresholds below, regardless of whether the business is based in California.
● DPDPA: Applies to the processing of digital personal data within India, and to processing outside India if it is in connection with offering goods or services to individuals in India.
2. Key terminologies
● GDPR: Core concepts such as ‘processing’, ‘controller’, ‘processor’ and ‘data subject’ are broadly consistent with the DPDPA’s ‘Data Fiduciary’, ‘Data Processor’ and ‘Data Principal’.
● CCPA (as amended by CPRA): A ‘business’ must comply if it has annual gross revenue above USD 25 million (adjusted for inflation), buys, sells or shares the personal information of 100,000 or more consumers or households, or derives 50% or more of its annual revenue from selling or sharing personal information. ‘Sale’ covers making personal information available to a third party for monetary or other valuable consideration.
● DPDPA: Introduces the ‘Significant Data Fiduciary’ (a Data Fiduciary notified by the Government based on factors such as the volume and sensitivity of data processed) and the ‘Consent Manager’ (a registered platform that enables individuals to give, manage, review and withdraw consent).
3. Personal data
● GDPR: ‘Personal data’ means any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person, such as a name, an identification number, location data or an online identifier. Special categories include racial or ethnic origin, political opinions, religious or philosophical beliefs, trade union membership, genetic data, biometric data, health data, and sex life or sexual orientation.
● CCPA (as amended by CPRA): ‘Personal information’ is information that identifies, relates to, describes, or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household. The CPRA added a category of ‘sensitive personal information’.
● DPDPA: ‘Personal data’ is any data about an individual who is identifiable by or in relation to such data. Unlike the GDPR, the DPDPA does not create separate categories based on the sensitivity of personal data.
4. Grounds of processing
● GDPR: Consent, performance of a contract, legitimate interests, public interest, vital interests and legal obligation.
● CCPA (as amended by CPRA): Does not require a legal basis for processing; businesses may process personal information for disclosed business purposes, backed by appropriate notices and opt-out rights.
● DPDPA: Consent, or certain ‘legitimate uses’ specified in Section 7 (such as employment purposes, medical emergencies and compliance with law).
5. Children’s data
● GDPR: Parental consent is required for offering online services to children under 16 (member states may lower this to 13).
● CCPA (as amended by CPRA): Businesses may not sell or share the personal information of consumers under 16 without affirmative authorisation — from a parent or guardian for children under 13, and from the consumer for those aged 13 to 16.
● DPDPA: Verifiable parental consent is required for processing the personal data of children under 18. Tracking, behavioural monitoring, targeted advertising directed at children, and processing likely to harm a child’s well-being are prohibited.
6. Rights of individuals
● GDPR: Right to be informed, access, rectification, erasure, restriction of processing, data portability, objection, and rights relating to automated decision-making.
● CCPA (as amended by CPRA): Right to know/access, delete, correct, opt out of the sale or sharing of personal information, limit the use of sensitive personal information, data portability, and non-discrimination for exercising these rights.
● DPDPA: Right to access information, correction and erasure, grievance redressal, and to nominate another person to exercise rights in the event of death or incapacity.
7. Compliance obligations
● GDPR: Controllers and processors must adhere to the principles of processing, implement technical and organisational measures, maintain records of processing, conduct Data Protection Impact Assessments for high-risk processing, appoint a Data Protection Officer where required, and the controller is accountable for compliance.
● CCPA (as amended by CPRA): Businesses must give notices at collection, honour consumer requests and maintain records of them, and enter into contracts with service providers. The CPRA provides for regulations requiring cybersecurity audits and risk assessments for high-risk processing. There is no requirement to appoint a DPO.
● DPDPA: Data Fiduciaries must give notices (with an option to access them in English or any of the 22 languages in the Eighth Schedule to the Constitution), obtain valid consent, implement reasonable security safeguards, and provide a grievance redressal mechanism. Significant Data Fiduciaries must also appoint a Data Protection Officer based in India, appoint an independent data auditor and conduct periodic Data Protection Impact Assessments.
8. Data breach
● GDPR: Controllers must notify the supervisory authority within 72 hours of becoming aware of a breach (unless it is unlikely to result in a risk), and notify affected individuals where the breach is likely to result in a high risk.
● CCPA (as amended by CPRA): Affected California residents must be notified of breaches of specified personal information, and the Attorney General must also be notified where a single breach affects more than 500 California residents.
● DPDPA: Data Fiduciaries must intimate every personal data breach to the Data Protection Board and to each affected Data Principal. Separately, cyber security incidents must be reported to CERT-In within 6 hours.
9. Penalties
● GDPR: Two tiers of administrative fines: up to €10 million or 2% of annual global turnover, and up to €20 million or 4% of annual global turnover, whichever is higher.
● CCPA (as amended by CPRA): Up to USD 2,500 for each violation and USD 7,500 for each intentional violation or violation involving the personal information of consumers under 16 (amounts are adjusted for inflation).
● DPDPA: Penalties of up to INR 250 crore per instance, depending on the nature of the breach. Unlike the GDPR, penalties are fixed amounts and are not linked to turnover.
10. Cross-border transfers
● GDPR: Permitted on the basis of an adequacy decision, appropriate safeguards (such as Standard Contractual Clauses or Binding Corporate Rules), or specified derogations.
● CCPA (as amended by CPRA): Does not specifically regulate cross-border transfers; transfers to service providers and contractors must be governed by contracts requiring them to protect the personal information.
● DPDPA: Cross-border transfers are permitted, except to countries or territories that the Central Government restricts by notification.
Conclusion
Given the evolving global data privacy landscape, the expansion of businesses across borders, stringent penalties, and rapid technological advancements, mere compliance with local data privacy laws will no longer suffice. Organisations must implement a global data privacy compliance framework to meet these requirements without disrupting their business operations.
Key Takeaways
● The GDPR, India's DPDP Act and the CCPA/CPRA are three major but divergent privacy frameworks, each with extra-territorial reach.
● Key divergences include the grounds of processing, the age thresholds for children's data (16, or as low as 13, under the GDPR; under 16 for sale or sharing under the CCPA; under 18 under the DPDPA), penalty structures and cross-border transfer rules.
● Indian IT/ITES businesses servicing EU or US clients must comply with multiple overlapping privacy regimes.
● Rights of access, correction and erasure are common across jurisdictions but differ in scope; the DPDPA uniquely adds a right to nominate.
● Multi-jurisdictional privacy compliance requires a unified framework with jurisdiction-specific adaptations.