Liquidation preference is the single most consequential economicterm in a venture investment — determining which investors get paid first andhow much in any exit scenario, from acquisition to winding up.
Liquidation preference right is a key constituent in private equity and venture capital transactions. A liquidation preference clause provides preference to the investors at the time of distribution of proceeds in a liquidation event or adeemed liquidation event, thereby, providing downside protection to the investors in such events. From an investment transactions standpoint, liquidation events typically include actual liquidation, winding-up or dissolution of the company or sale of material assets or any corporate reorganization, transfer of securities or any other transaction that results In a change of control.
Types of Liquidation Preference
● Participating Liquidation Preference: Participating liquidation preference means that in addition to the preferential payment that the investor receives out of the distribution of liquidation event proceeds, the investor is also entitled to participate in the surplus liquidation proceeds remaining after payment of the preferential amount to the investor in proportion to the shareholding of theinvestor on an as-converted basis. This is also commonly known as a double dip.
● Non-Participating Liquidation Preference: Non-participating liquidation preference means that investors will not be entitled to participate in the distribution of surplus liquidation proceeds which are available for distribution among the other shareholders of the company.
Standard Liquidation Preference Construct
A standardnon-participating liquidation preference clause is as follows:
“Upon the occurrence of a liquidation event, the investor shall be entitled to receive from the total proceeds of such liquidation event remaining after discharging all liabilities of the company in accordance with applicable law, in preference to the other shareholders, the higher of:
● 1xof the amounts invested by the investor; and
● Pro-ratashare of the investor in the liquidation proceeds in proportion to the shareholding of the investor in the company on an as-converted basis.”
Generally,the downside protection in liquidation preference clauses is set in terms of aninvestment multiple which is typically pegged between 1x to 2x of theinvestment amount. The commonly used liquidation preference mechanism is anon-participating liquidation preference with a 1x multiple, which ensures that the investors take away at least their investment amount. Further, in the eventthe liquidation proceeds are insufficient for the payment of the liquidation preference amount of the investor, then the investor is entitled to take awaythe entire liquidation proceeds. A clause to that effect is incorporated in theliquidation preference construct.
Illustrations
“X” hasinvested an amount of INR 1,00,00,000 (Indian Rupees One Crore) in “ABC PrivateLimited” and holds 10% (Ten Percent) of the share capital of ABC PrivateLimited on an as-converted basis.
LP Mechanism| Liquidation Proceeds | Entitlement as per Multiple (A) | Entitlement as perShareholding (B) | Participation in Surplus Liquidation Proceeds (C) | ActualPayment Amount (D)
(Higher ofthe two is considered)
Non-Participating(1x) | 5,00,00,000 | 1,00,00,000 | 50,00,000 | – | 1,00,00,000
Non-Participating(2x) | 5,00,00,000 | 2,00,00,000 | 50,00,000 | – | 2,00,00,000
Participating(1x) | 5,00,00,000 | 1,00,00,000 | 50,00,000 | 40,00,000 | 1,40,00,000 (A + C)
Participating(2x) | 5,00,00,000 | 2,00,00,000 | 50,00,000 | 40,00,000 | 2,40,00,000 (A + C)
Non-Participating(1x) | 1,00,00,000 | 1,00,00,000 | 10,00,000 | – | 1,00,00,000
Non-Participating(1x) | 50,00,000 | 1,00,00,000 | 5,00,000 | – | 50,00,000
Non-Participating(1x) | 20,00,00,000 | 1,00,00,000 | 2,00,00,000 | – | 2,00,00,000
Non-Participating(2x) | 30,00,00,000 | 2,00,00,000 | 3,00,00,000 | – | 3,00,00,000
Participating(2x) | 30,00,00,000 | 2,00,00,000 | 3,00,00,000 | 1,70,00,000 | 4,70,00,000 (B+ C)
In eachscenario above, the liquidation proceeds remaining after payment of the actual payment amount (set out in column D) will be distributed among the other shareholders on a pro-rata basis in proportion to their shareholding on anas-converted basis.
Liquidation Preference for Multiple Investors
In cases where a company has multiple investors, liquidation preference rights may begiven to them either on a pari-passu basis such that all the investors haveseniority in payment of liquidation proceeds basis their proportion ateshareholding or through a waterfall mechanism whereby holders of a particularclass of securities (typically, securities issued to investors in the latestfunding round) get preferential right above all other class of securities. Forexample, in a company that has had a Seed Funding Round (wherein Seed SeriesSecurities were issued) and a Series A Round (wherein Series A Securities wereissued), either Seed Round Investors and Series A Investors, both, may havepari-passu liquidation preference or the holders of Series A Securities mayhave seniority over holders of Seed Series Securities.
Enforceability of Liquidation Preference Rights
Section 43(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 provides that the share capital of a company limited by shares can either be equity share capital or preference share capital. Further, preference shares carry a preferential right with respect to payment of dividends and repayment in case of liquidation, winding-up or repayment of capital of the company.
Section 47 of the Companies Act, 2013 provides for a distinction between equity shares and preference shares in terms of the voting rights attached to such shares. Whileholders of equity shares are entitled to vote on every resolution placed beforethe company, holders of preference shares can only vote on matters which directly affect the rights attached to the preference shares or with respect towinding-up or repayment of capital of the company.
However, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, vide notification dated June 5, 2015, notified that private companies may be exempt from the applicability of Section 43 andSection 47 where the memorandum of association and articles of association ofthe company provide for such exemption. Therefore, pursuant to the saidnotification, private companies can issue preference shares with voting rightsrather than issuing equity shares with differential voting rights and mayprovide preferential rights of payment to the holders thereof. Having saidthat, it must be noted that the enforceability of the liquidation preferencemechanism has not been tested in Indian courts. Further, implementation of aliquidation preference right would have its own challenges on a case-to-casebasis and may have to be looked into from an exchange control laws perspectiveand taxation standpoint.
Key Takeaways
● Liquidation preference determines the order and amount of distributions to investors beforecommon shareholders in any exit scenario.
● Non-participating preference shares give investors their liquidation preference but notadditional participation in remaining proceeds.
● Participating preference shares allow investors to receive both the liquidation preferenceand a pro-rata share of remaining proceeds.
● Multiple liquidation preference (e.g., 2x or 3x) significantly increases investorreturns but reduces founder exit proceeds.
● Founders should model various exit scenarios to understand the real economic impact of different liquidation preference structures.