Corporate Law
April 29, 2023

Representations and Warranties Insurance In M&A Transactions

Representations and Warranties Insurance is rapidly gainingtraction in Indian M&A — it bridges the indemnification gap in transactionswhere sellers are unwilling to provide full contractual recourse post-closing.

‍

Representations and Warranties

Representationsand warranties (“R&Ws”) are an integral part of M&A transactions acrossthe globe. R&Ws are a set of factual representations and warranties thatare made by sellers in secondary investment transactions with respect tovarious aspects of the target entity’s business. These warranties are providedas of the date of execution of transaction documents and are repeated on thedate of consummation of the transaction. Typically, R&Ws are bifurcatedinto three categories, i.e., fundamental warranties, business/operationwarranties and tax warranties. Additionally, R&Ws also includerepresentations in respect of the authority and capacity of the parties toexecute and perform the transaction documents. R&Ws act as an inducementfor buyers to invest in the target entities. Over the years, the M&A markethas grown tremendously in terms of number of deals and deal volume.Resultantly, R&Ws have become increasingly significant in M&Atransactions as a risk allocation tool.

Significance of R&Ws

R&Ws aregenerally backed by indemnity protection and in the absence of indemnity may beconsidered as a misrepresentation or a breach of warranty which is remediableby way of damages. Although buyers conduct due diligence investigations intothe business and affairs of the target entities to identify piston-compliances and potential risks, it is practically difficult to solely relyon the findings of such investigations as their scope is limited in nature and their findings are heavily based on the information and documents provided by the sellers and the target entities. Hence, R&Ws are quintessential to protect buyers from potential liabilities that may arise from identified and unidentified risks.

Role of R&W Insurance

Given the risks involved on both sides, R&W insurance is a viable solution as it shifts the financial liabilities arising from inaccuracy or breach of R&W sto the insurer company. Both the warrantor and the buyer may procure R&W insurance. In a buyer’s R&W insurance, the buyer is entitled to directly make a claim with the insurance company without having to necessarily seek indemnity from the sellers. Whereas in a seller’s R&W insurance, the sellers entitled to make a claim with the insurance company for any costs incurred by the seller owing to any claims made by the buyer for inaccuracy or breach of R&Ws. Conventionally, alternate methods of sourcing funds for indemnity claims have been resorted to by the parties, which include escrow of fraction of consideration, a holdback of consideration and set-off mechanism. Often, this means that sellers do not receive the entire consideration on the date of consummation of the transaction as the escrowed or the holdback amount is received upon the expiry of the claims period or the agreed time period in the contract. R&W insurance helps in the mitigation or elimination of conventional methods of escrow and holdback to allow sellers to receive the maximum or the full amount of consideration on the closing date. However, inmany deals, it has been observed that R&W insurance is obtained by thebuyer as a safeguard over and above such conventional methods. R&Winsurance has also been seen to be useful in acquisition deals where none ofthe sellers hold a controlling stake in the target entity and/or are notcomfortable giving R&Ws for the target’s business on a joint and severalbasis. Buyers prefer a buy-side R&W insurance in cases where the sellersare expected to continue to be involved in the target’s business as it givesthem the ability to avoid making direct claims against sellers which may helpsustain relationships. Furthermore, it acts as appropriate protection for thebuyers where there are concerns around the financial ability of the sellers topay or in cases where buyers foresee challenges in the enforcement ofcontractual indemnity protections against the sellers.

Key Aspects of R&W Insurance

Insurancecontracts are based on the underlying principle of uberrima fides, i.e., utmostgood faith. This means that the parties to an insurance policy must negotiatein good faith and make an accurate and complete disclosure of all materialfacts related to the subject matter of insurance. Since disclosures are anintegral part of such insurance policies, insurance companies conduct their owndue diligence on the target entity’s business and affairs to identify potentialrisks. Buyer and seller are also expected to conduct due diligence on thetarget’s business and share the reports of such investigations with theinsurance company; else, it may end up affecting the scope of insurance,coverage and the insurance amount amongst other things. Due diligence findingshelp insurance companies identify exclusions to coverage under R&W insurance policies. Typically, any breach of covenants by sellers andpost-closing adjustments are not covered. Any concealment of fact,misrepresentation, omission or fraudulent non-disclosure will result in adischarge of liability of the insurer. Any breach of R&Ws which the insuredhad knowledge about is not covered. Hence, specific indemnity matters andmatters disclosed by sellers in the disclosure letter may not be covered. Thiscould mean that material issues identified by buyers in due diligence may bespecifically excluded from insurance coverage. This is also the reason whyR&W insurance cannot be treated as a complete alternative to conventionalremedies available to the buyer. Furthermore, pecuniary and temporallimitations are customary exceptions to insurance coverage, wherein pecuniarylimitations would include deductibles which would typically be a percentage ofthe total consideration and temporal limitations would include the survivalperiod of R&Ws which would typically be aligned with the agreed limitationsin the contract.

Conclusion

The usage of R&W insurance in M&A transactions is undoubtedly on the rise and continually evolving. Given the limitations of R&W insurance as a tool for recovery of claims liability relevant from an M&A standpoint, it may not be the ultimate solution but definitely acts as a safety net for warrantors and provides them considerable peace of mind. There is no one-size-fits-all model of R&W insurance; it would rather make more sense to assess the viability of R&W insurance on a case-to-case basis since such insurances are tailor-made following a thorough consideration of all relevant facts pertaining to the target’s business. In a nutshell, R&W insurance must be viewed as a risk management tool as opposed to a risk-elimination tool.

Key Takeaways

● R&W Insurance shifts indemnification obligations from the seller to an insurer,enabling cleaner exits and reducing escrow requirements.

● The policy typically covers breaches of seller representations and warrantiesdiscovered after closing.

● R&W Insurance is increasingly used in PE-backed transactions as sponsors prefer tolimit post-closing indemnity exposure.

● Premiumrates in India typically range from 2-4% of the policy limit depending on dealcomplexity and sector.

● Due diligence quality directly impacts R&W Insurance underwriting — thorough diligence reduces premiums and enhances coverage.

‍

Related Insights