Litigation
February 13, 2026

Decoding Heirship vs. Succession: Navigating the Maze of Inheritance

A nominee is not a beneficial owner — they are a trustee for thelegal heirs: the Supreme Court has definitively settled this in Shakti Yezdaniv. Jayanand Salgaonkar, clarifying that nomination under the Companies Act andDepositories Act does not override the law of succession.

Introduction

Inheritancein India is shaped by a patchwork of personal laws, statutes, and judicialinterpretations. A fundamental question persists: is there a difference betweena legal heir and a nominee? While a legal heir is entitled by substantivesuccession law to inherit assets, a nominee is generally authorised only toreceive assets as a custodian on behalf of legal heirs. Understanding thedistinction between heirship and succession, the roles of nominees versus legalheirs, and the statutory requirements for transferring assets is essential toavoid protracted disputes and stress for families.

Legal HeirCertificate vs. Succession Certificate

A Legal HeirCertificate (LHC) is an administrative document issued by the Civil Court thatidentifies the survivors of the deceased, primarily for non-financial purposessuch as accessing family pensions, gratuity, provident fund, or transferringutility connections and immovable properties. Courts have consistently heldthat an LHC is not a document of title. In State of Chhattisgarh v. DhirjoKumar Sengar (2009) 13 SCC 600, the Supreme Court clarified that a successioncertificate is the primary document for debts and securities, while an LHC islimited to administrative recognition. A Succession Certificate, issued underSection 370 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, is mandatorily required toinherit debts and securities including movable financial assets like bankdeposits, mutual funds, and shares in the absence of a Will. Under Section 381of the Act, it affords full indemnity to all persons who pay debts or deliversecurities to the certificate holder.

Nominee vs.Legal Heir: The Trustee Principle

A criticalambiguity long plagued wealth management: does a nominee supersede a legalheir? The Bombay High Court in Harsha Nitin Kokate v. The Saraswat Co-operativeBank (2010) had suggested a nominee becomes the absolute owner of shares. Thisconflicted with the established position in Sarbati Devi v. Usha Devi (1984) 1SCC 424, where the Supreme Court held that a nominee for an LIC policy ismerely a receiver, not an owner. The Supreme Court definitively resolved thisconflict in Shakti Yezdani & Anr. v. Jayanand Jayant Salgaonkar & Ors.(2023 SCC OnLine SC 1679). The Court ruled that the Companies Act, 2013 andDepositories Act, 1996 are not intended to rewrite the law of succession. Anon-obstante clause in corporate regulations helps the company discharge itsliability but does not grant beneficial title to the nominee. The TrusteePrinciple stands: a nominee receives the asset to ensure the company or bank isnot dragged into litigation, but must hold it in trust for the rightful legalheirs identified under the relevant Succession Act.

Conclusion

LegalHeirship is an administrative status certification primarily used for claimingbenefits and establishing identity of heirs. Succession is a judicial processspecifically designed for recovering debts and securities with legalprotection. Practitioners must carefully assess which document is appropriatebased on the specific assets involved, the nature of claims, and institutionalrequirements. In many cases, both documents may be required for differentpurposes in settling an estate.

Key Takeaways

• Anominee under the Companies Act, 2013 or Depositories Act, 1996 is not abeneficial owner — per the Supreme Court in Shakti Yezdani (2023), a nomineeholds assets as a trustee for the rightful legal heirs identified under theapplicable Succession Act.

• ALegal Heir Certificate is an administrative document used for non-financialpurposes (pensions, gratuity, utility transfers); it is not a document of titleand cannot substitute for a Succession Certificate in claiming financialassets.

• A Succession Certificate under Section 370 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 is mandatorily required to recover movable financial assets (bank deposits, mutual funds, shares) in the absence of a Will; it provides full indemnity to persons who deliver assets to the certificate holder.

• Thenon-obstante clause in corporate nomination provisions protects the companyfrom liability by permitting asset delivery to the nominee, but does notoverride substantive succession law or confer ownership on the nominee.

• Estate settlement planning should include clear nomination records, updated Wills, and identification of both the legal heirs under applicable personal law and the nominated persons across financial instruments to avoid post-death disputes.

‍

Related Insights